Choosing the right practitioner
This page is written to be useful whether or not you come to us. The questions below apply to any clinic, and we would rather you ask them of everyone — including Me Clinic — than not ask them at all.
First: check the registration yourself
Before anything else, look the practitioner up on the public register at ahpra.gov.au. It takes under a minute and tells you their registration type, any endorsements, and any conditions on their practice. See how to read a register entry field by field.
Understand what the titles mean:
- Specialist Plastic Surgeon — a protected title requiring Fellowship of the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons (FRACS) in plastic and reconstructive surgery.
- Cosmetic Doctor / medical practitioner — a registered doctor with general registration. They may lawfully perform many cosmetic procedures.
- “Cosmetic surgeon” — a title restricted since 1 July 2023, with endorsement requiring specified standards.
- There is no AHPRA specialty of “cosmetic surgery”. A clinic claiming “specialist registration in cosmetic surgery” is describing something that does not exist.
A registration number should be published beside every practitioner’s name. If you cannot find one, ask for it.
How to run the consultation, not just attend it
Most people arrive having thought hard about the procedure and not at all about the appointment. An hour prepared differently produces a much better decision.
Before you go
- Write your questions down, in order of what matters most. You will not remember them otherwise, and reading from a list is not rude.
- Write down what actually bothers you, specifically — the situation, not the body part.
- Bring your medication list, including over-the-counter products, supplements and anything bought online.
- Bring someone with you. Two people remember more than one, and a second person notices pressure that you are too invested to see.
- Decide in advance that you will not book today. This single decision changes the dynamic of the whole appointment.
In the room
- Take notes, or ask to record the explanation. Most practitioners will agree; the reaction is informative either way.
- Ask for everything in writing — the plan, the risks, the quote with inclusions, the revision policy, the aftercare instructions.
- Say the sentence. “I’m not going to book today — can you give me all of that in writing so I can read it properly at home?” A good clinic says yes without hesitation and often encourages it. Any resistance to that request is the most useful information you will get all day.
- Ask what they would advise if you did nothing.
- Notice who does the talking about the clinical detail, and whether money is discussed before the medicine.
Afterwards
- Write down your impressions the same day, before they blur into the next appointment.
- Read the risk information at home, when nobody is waiting.
- Notice how you feel a week later, which is exactly what the cooling-off period exists to let you do.
Questions to ask the surgeon or doctor
- What is your registration type and number, and where did you train?
- Have you performed this specific procedure, and roughly how many times?
- What are the realistic risks and complications for me, given my history?
- What is the recovery, honestly — not the best case?
- Who does my post-operative care, and who do I call after hours if something goes wrong?
- Will you be performing the procedure, or someone else?
- Where is it performed, and is the facility accredited?
- What anaesthetic, and who administers it?
- Can I see before and after photographs of your own patients with a similar starting point to mine?
- What does the quoted price include — and what is not included?
- What happens, and what does it cost, if a revision is needed?
- What would you advise if I decided not to proceed?
A practitioner who welcomes these questions is telling you something. So is one who deflects them.
A sheet for comparing clinics
If you are seeing more than one practitioner — and for surgery you should — the memory of a consultation fades fast and blurs into the next. Record the same twelve things after each appointment and the comparison makes itself.
| Record | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Who will operate, and their registration number | The person, not the practice, holds the registration |
| Their registration type and specialty as shown on the register | Should match the title used in the marketing |
| How many of this procedure in the last 12 months | More useful than a career total |
| The facility, and whether it is accredited | Where a problem would be managed |
| Who gives the anaesthetic | A specialist anaesthetist bills separately |
| Total quoted, and exactly what is inside it | A single figure is not a quote |
| What is explicitly excluded | Usually where the surprises live |
| Revision policy, and who pays theatre and anaesthetist | A waived surgeon’s fee is not a free operation |
| The three risks they emphasised | What a practitioner leads with is informative |
| The after-hours contact, and who answers it | The thing you will care most about at 2am |
| What they said you should not do | Anyone who said nothing is a flag |
| How you felt walking out | Write it the same day |
Two patterns are worth watching for across the sheet. A quote that is much lower than the others usually has something outside it — find out what before treating it as cheaper. And a clinic that emphasised no risks at all is not safer than the one that did; it is less forthcoming.
Questions to ask yourself
- Is this the right procedure for what actually bothers me?
- Why now? Is there a life event or a relationship driving this that will still be there afterwards?
- Am I confident in this practitioner’s experience with this procedure?
- Am I comfortable with the practitioner, the nursing staff and the facility?
- Do I understand the recovery, and have I arranged the time and help I will need?
- Am I choosing on cost or on competence?
- Have I given myself time to think, or am I being moved along?
A consultation versus a sales meeting
The difference is usually obvious in retrospect and easy to miss at the time. A few reliable tells:
| A consultation | A sales meeting |
|---|---|
| The practitioner examines you before discussing options | A plan is described before anyone has looked properly |
| The clinical conversation comes before the money | A non-clinical consultant handles the money first |
| You are told what will not work, and why | Everything you mention is achievable |
| Risks are explained and given to you in writing | Risks are mentioned briefly and moved past |
| Doing nothing is presented as a real option | Doing nothing is not mentioned |
| You are encouraged to go away and think | There is a reason today is better |
| You leave with a written, itemised quote | You leave with a figure and a feeling |
| They ask what you are hoping will change | They tell you how you will feel afterwards |
None of this means a clinic with a consultant is bad — someone has to explain scheduling and payment. The question is the order, and who answers the clinical questions.
Warning signs worth walking away from
- Pressure to decide today, or a discount that expires if you go home and think about it
- No referral requested for cosmetic surgery — a referral has been required since 1 July 2023, and a clinic skipping it is skipping a rule
- One consultation and a booking — two consultations are required before cosmetic surgery is booked, one of them in person with the operating surgeon
- Risks glossed over, or a promise of a guaranteed result
- Testimonials and influencer content — prohibited in advertising regulated health services
- Before and after images that are not the clinic’s own patients, or that are visibly retouched or shot under different lighting
- Vague titles — “specialist” used loosely, or a registration number you cannot find
- No clear answer on aftercare or on who handles complications
- Price quoted without written inclusions
- Being talked into more than you came for
- A deposit requested before you have been examined
- Finance offered before the risks have been explained
Get a second opinion
We recommend seeking a second medical opinion before any surgical procedure — ideally from a registered Specialist Plastic Surgeon with knowledge of the specific area. That recommendation stands whether or not the first opinion was ours.
We also provide second opinions for people who have consulted elsewhere, including reviewing a plan you have already been quoted for.
To make one useful: go somewhere genuinely independent rather than a colleague in the same practice, take your notes and your written quote, and ask the second practitioner “what would you do differently, and why?” rather than whether the first plan was reasonable. Asking the second question invites agreement; asking the first invites thought.
If you are considering treatment overseas
Everything on this page still applies, and two things become harder: verifying qualifications against a register you understand, and getting aftercare when you are back home and something is wrong. Read the risks of overseas cosmetic surgery before committing to anything.
About Me Clinic specifically
We have practised cosmetic medicine and surgery in Melbourne for over 35 years, from a full-time medical clinic at 4 Burke Road, Malvern East.
Our Specialist Plastic Surgeons are Dr Gary Kode (MED0001405964), Dr Amir Tadros (MED0002302612) and Dr Mark Doyle (MED0001375519). Our Cosmetic Doctors are Dr Gordon Ku (MED0001169203), Dr Kwok Hao Lie (MED0001843582) and Dr Luis Torres Villacorta (MED0002049692). Dr Tim French (MED0001790529) practises in phlebology — which is not an AHPRA-recognised specialty, a distinction we state rather than blur.
Each is willing to discuss their qualifications, experience and training with you directly, and to show before and after photographs of their own patients — genuine images, with the reminder that results vary between individuals.
Booking
Me Clinic, 4 Burke Road, Malvern East VIC 3145. Phone 1300 852 050 or (03) 9569 3511, or use the online consultation form. Consultations as at September 2024, including GST: Specialist Plastic Surgeon $350, Cosmetic Doctor $150. We are not a no-gap provider.
Related: cosmetic surgery rule changes, risks of overseas cosmetic surgery, risks and complications.
Individual results may vary. Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks. Before proceeding you should seek a second opinion from an appropriately qualified health practitioner.
Common questions about choosing a practitioner
What should I do first?
Look the practitioner up on the public register at ahpra.gov.au. It takes under a minute and shows registration type, endorsements and any conditions.
What does “Specialist Plastic Surgeon” mean?
A protected title requiring Fellowship of the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons in plastic and reconstructive surgery.
Is “cosmetic surgery” a specialty?
No. A clinic claiming specialist registration in cosmetic surgery is describing something that does not exist.
What if a registration number is not published?
Ask for it. Practitioners have been required to state their registration type and number since 1 July 2023.
How should I prepare for a consultation?
Write your questions down in order, write down specifically what bothers you, bring your medication list, bring someone with you, and decide in advance that you will not book that day.
What is the single most useful thing to say?
“I’m not going to book today — can you give me all of that in writing so I can read it properly at home?” The reaction tells you a great deal.
Can I record the consultation?
Ask. Most practitioners will agree, and the reaction is informative either way.
What should I ask the surgeon?
Registration and training; how many of this procedure they have done; realistic risks for you; honest recovery; who does aftercare and who answers after hours; whether they personally will operate; the facility and its accreditation; the anaesthetic and who gives it; their own patients’ photographs; what the price includes and excludes; revision cost; and what they would advise if you did not proceed.
How do I compare two or three clinics?
Record the same twelve items after each appointment — who operates, their registration, annual volume, facility, anaesthetist, total quote, exclusions, revision policy, the risks they emphasised, the after-hours contact, what they said you should not do, and how you felt.
What if one quote is much lower?
Something is probably outside it. Find out what before treating it as cheaper.
Is a clinic that mentions no risks safer?
No — it is less forthcoming.
How do I tell a consultation from a sales meeting?
In a consultation you are examined before options are discussed, the clinical conversation precedes the money, you are told what will not work, risks are given in writing, doing nothing is presented as real, and you leave with an itemised quote.
Is it a problem if a non-clinical consultant is involved?
Not in itself — someone has to explain scheduling and payment. The question is the order, and who answers the clinical questions.
What should I ask myself?
Whether this is the right procedure for what actually bothers you; why now; whether you are confident in this practitioner for this procedure; whether you understand the recovery; whether you are choosing on cost or competence; and whether you have given yourself time.
What are the clearest warning signs?
Pressure to decide today, an expiring discount, no referral requested, one consultation and a booking, risks glossed over, testimonials, images that are not their patients, vague titles, no aftercare answer, a price without written inclusions, and being talked into more than you came for.
Should I get a second opinion?
Yes, before any surgical procedure, ideally from a registered Specialist Plastic Surgeon — whether or not the first opinion was ours.
How do I make a second opinion useful?
Go somewhere genuinely independent, take your notes and written quote, and ask what they would do differently and why.
What if I am considering going overseas?
Everything here still applies, and verifying qualifications and getting aftercare both become harder. Read the page on the risks of overseas cosmetic surgery first.
What does a consultation cost here?
$350 with a Specialist Plastic Surgeon and $150 with a Cosmetic Doctor, including GST as at September 2024.
Images on This Page
-
https://www.meclinic.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/meclinic-logo.png
Me Clinic
-
https://www.meclinic.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/call.png
call
-
https://www.meclinic.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/acps.png
(no alt text)
-
https://www.meclinic.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/racs.png
(no alt text)
-
https://www.meclinic.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/fracs.png
(no alt text)
-
https://www.meclinic.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/isaps.png
(no alt text)
-
https://www.meclinic.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2024/02/cpca.png
(no alt text)
-
https://www.meclinic.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/auscop.png
(no alt text)
-
https://www.meclinic.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/amav.png
(no alt text)
-
https://www.meclinic.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2022/02/malvern-map-thumb.jpg
(no alt text)
-
https://www.meclinic.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/home-conctact-tab.jpg
(no alt text)
-
https://bat.bing.com/action/0?ti=56339805&Ver=2&mid=8952cf79-f463-4cb2-9b31-9bf99f76efe0&bo=1&sid=ca181070ac3311f19d999be145109970&vid=ca188030ac3311f194edadbdef6ca430&vids=0&msclkid=N&pi=918639831&lg=en-US&sw=1280&sh=720&sc=24&tl=Choosing%20the%20Right%20Cosmetic%20Surgeon%3A%20Tips%20and%20Advice&p=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.meclinic.com.au%2Fwhy-the-me-clinic%2Fchoosing-the-right-cosmetic-practitioner%2F&r=<=3123&evt=pageLoad&sv=2&cdb=AQAQ&rn=90656
(no alt text)