Surgical excision

Surgical excision removes a lesion by cutting it out completely, along with a margin of surrounding skin, and closing the wound with sutures.

It is the most definitive way of removing a skin lesion, and the only one that reliably answers the question what was it.

Why excision is different from every other method

Laser, cryotherapy, radiofrequency and curettage all destroy or fragment the lesion. Excision removes it whole — which means it can be sent to a pathologist, who can determine exactly what it was and whether the margins are clear.

That difference is the reason this page exists. If a lesion might be a skin cancer, destroying it leaves:

Excision costs you a line scar. In exchange you get certainty. For anything suspicious, that is not a close call. See skin cancers.

When excision is the right method

When it is not

What happens

  1. The area is cleaned and marked. The excision is planned as an ellipse, aligned wherever possible with a natural skin crease or relaxed skin tension line — which is what makes a scar less noticeable later.
  2. Local anaesthetic is injected. You feel a sting for a few seconds, then nothing but pressure.
  3. The lesion is removed with an appropriate margin.
  4. The wound is closed with sutures, sometimes in two layers — deep dissolving sutures to take the tension, fine surface sutures for the skin.
  5. The specimen is sent to pathology.
  6. A dressing is applied, and you are given wound care instructions and a follow-up date.

Most excisions take 20 to 45 minutes. Larger excisions, and those needing a flap or graft to close, are performed by our Specialist Plastic Surgeons.

Results from pathology usually take about a week. You are told the result either way, and what it means for you.

You stay awake and you can talk. Nothing is being done that you cannot ask about while it happens, and it is entirely reasonable to say you would rather not watch, or to ask for a break. Most people find the anticipation worse than the procedure.

Why the margin is the whole point

A margin is a rim of normal-looking skin taken around the lesion. It is not caution for its own sake — it is what makes the pathology report meaningful.

If a lesion is cut out exactly at its visible edge, a pathologist can tell you what it was but cannot tell you whether any of it was left behind, because there is no normal tissue at the edge to prove the abnormal tissue stopped. With a margin, the report can state whether the lesion was completely removed. That single sentence is the difference between finishing the matter and not knowing.

How wide the margin is depends on what the lesion is suspected to be, where it sits, and how much skin is available to close. A margin on the back can be generous; a margin beside the eyelid cannot. That is why the same diagnosis can be handled differently on different parts of the body, and why a surgeon may take a narrow margin first and a wider one after the diagnosis is known.

How to read your pathology report

You are entitled to a copy of your own report, and it is worth asking for one and keeping it. If a lesion ever recurs at the site, or a future practitioner needs to know what was there, that piece of paper is the record. Four things on it matter:

“Incompletely excised” is not an emergency and is not a mistake. Lesions do not have visible borders that match their true extent, and a margin judged by eye is sometimes narrower than it needed to be. What it means practically is a second, wider procedure at the same site, usually planned rather than urgent, and discussed with you before it is booked.

No news is good news is not a system

Before you leave, establish four things:

  1. When the result is expected — usually about a week.
  2. Who will contact you, and how — and that they will contact you either way, not only if something is wrong.
  3. What number to ring if you have not heard by the date you were given.
  4. Who holds the result if you move or change practitioners.

Results are chased by people, and people are fallible. If the date passes, ring. Nobody will think you are being difficult.

The scar, honestly

Excision always leaves a permanent scar, and the scar is always longer than the lesion was. That is not a shortcoming of technique: closing a circular defect without a bunched or puckered edge requires an elliptical excision several times the length of the lesion.

Put concretely, a 6mm mole typically gives a scar two to three times its diameter, and sometimes more. If you were expecting a 6mm mark to become a 6mm line, that expectation is worth resetting now rather than at the dressing change. The bunching at each end of a short closure is called a dog ear, and lengthening the ellipse is how it is avoided.

A well-planned scar fades from red to pale over 12 to 18 months and, on the face, sits along a line the eye does not read as out of place. It does not disappear. See scarring.

Where it is on your body changes everything

The same operation behaves differently by site, and this is the part people are least often told.

SiteSutures outWhat to expect of the scar
Face5–7 daysUsually the best scars anywhere — good blood supply, low tension, and creases to hide a line in
Neck and scalp7–10 daysGenerally good; hair-bearing scalp hides a line well
Trunk, especially back and chest10–14 daysThe most likely to widen or thicken. Skin here is under constant tension and scars stretch over months even when the surgery was faultless.
Over a joint — shoulder, knee, elbow10–14 daysMovement pulls on the wound with every use. Widening is common.
Lower leg and ankle14 days or longerThe slowest healing site on the body. Poor circulation, gravity and swelling all work against it, and this is where wound problems are most likely.

If a lesion on your back or lower leg is being excised, plan for the healing rather than the appointment. Heavy lifting, gym work and long days on your feet are what open wounds and widen scars.

Things that change the plan — tell us all of them

Blood thinners and anti-platelet medication

Do not stop any blood-thinning medication on your own before a skin procedure. This is the most important sentence on this page. Warfarin, apixaban, rivaroxaban, clopidogrel, aspirin and similar medicines are prescribed for reasons — strokes, clots, stents — and stopping them unilaterally for a small skin operation is a far greater risk than any bleeding it might prevent. Most minor skin surgery is performed without stopping them at all. Tell us what you take, and any decision to alter it is made with the doctor who prescribed it, never by you and never by us alone.

Diabetes

Healing is slower and infection more likely, particularly on the legs. It changes aftercare and follow-up intervals, not whether the procedure happens.

Smoking

Nicotine narrows the small vessels that feed a healing wound. Smokers have more wound breakdown, more infection and worse scars, and the effect is real enough to be worth a pause before and after — even a short one helps.

A keloid tendency

If you have made a thick, raised, spreading scar before — particularly on the chest, shoulders or earlobes — say so before anything is planned. It changes where and whether an elective excision is a good idea, and it changes what is done afterwards.

Previous treatment at the same site

A lesion frozen, burned or lasered before behaves differently and can be harder to interpret under the microscope. Bring what you know.

Older, thinner skin

Skin thinned by age or long-term steroid use tears more easily and holds sutures less well. Closure and dressings are chosen accordingly.

Pregnancy

Cosmetic excision is deferred. A lesion that needs removing for medical reasons is not.

Aftercare

Expected, versus call us, versus call 000

Risks

See risks and complications of cosmetic surgery.

What you receive

Cost and Medicare

Cost depends on the lesion, its size and site, and the complexity of closure. As at September 2024 and including GST, a Cosmetic Doctor consultation is $150 and a Specialist Plastic Surgeon consultation is $350. Pathology is charged separately by the laboratory.

Excision of a medically indicated lesion — a suspected cancer, a symptomatic lesion — generally attracts a Medicare rebate. MBS item 45060 covers removal of a skin cancer with flap or graft repair, among other applicable items. Excision for purely cosmetic reasons does not. We are not a no-gap provider, so an out-of-pocket cost applies; you are given the expected gap beforehand.

If several lesions are removed at one appointment, the billing can differ lesion by lesion — three treated cosmetically and one medically in the same visit is an ordinary outcome, not a mistake on the invoice. Ask for it to be itemised that way so you can see which is which.

Booking

Me Clinic, 4 Burke Road, Malvern East VIC 3145. Phone 1300 852 050 or (03) 9569 3511, or use the online consultation form.

Related: mole removal surgery, skin cancers, all skin treatments.

Common questions about surgical excision

What is surgical excision?

The lesion is cut out completely along with a margin of surrounding skin, and the wound is closed with sutures. It is the most definitive removal method and the only one that reliably answers what the lesion was.

Why does the method matter?

Laser, cryotherapy, radiofrequency and curettage destroy or fragment the lesion. Excision removes it whole, so it can go to a pathologist who can say what it was and whether the margins are clear.

What do you lose by destroying a lesion instead?

No diagnosis, no confirmation it was fully removed, no record in your file that it existed, and nothing for a future practitioner to refer back to if something recurs at the site.

Why is a margin taken?

Because without a rim of normal tissue at the edge, a pathologist cannot say whether any of the lesion was left behind. The margin is what allows the report to state that it was completely removed.

Why is the margin different on different parts of the body?

Because it depends on what the lesion is suspected to be, where it is, and how much skin is available to close. A margin on the back can be generous; one beside the eyelid cannot.

Does it hurt?

Local anaesthetic stings for a few seconds when it goes in. After that you feel pressure and movement but not pain. You stay awake and can ask about anything as it happens.

How long does it take?

Most excisions take 20 to 45 minutes. Larger ones, and those needing a flap or graft to close, are done by our Specialist Plastic Surgeons.

How long do results take?

Usually about a week. You are told the result either way, and what it means for you.

Should I get a copy of my pathology report?

Yes, and keep it. If anything recurs at the site, or a future practitioner needs to know what was there, that report is the record.

What do I look for on the report?

The diagnosis; whether the margins are clear or involved, often with a measurement; the depth where relevant, which for melanoma is the Breslow thickness in millimetres; and any recommendation for wider excision or referral.

Does a lesion being sent to pathology mean it is probably cancer?

No. Most excised lesions come back benign. Excision is done to rule things out as much as to confirm them, and a lesion being sent is not a prediction.

What does “incompletely excised” mean?

Abnormal cells reached the cut edge. It is not an emergency and not a mistake — lesions do not have visible borders that match their true extent. It usually means a second, wider procedure at the same site, planned rather than urgent.

What should I establish before I leave?

When the result is expected, who will contact you and how, that they will contact you either way, what number to ring if you have not heard by that date, and who holds the result if you move.

What if I do not hear anything?

Ring. No news is good news is not a system — results are chased by people, and people are fallible.

How big will the scar be?

Always longer than the lesion. A 6mm mole typically gives a scar two to three times its diameter. Closing a round defect without bunching requires an ellipse several times the length of the lesion.

Why not just cut out a circle?

Because the ends bunch into what is called a dog ear. Lengthening the excision into an ellipse is how that is avoided.

Will the scar go away?

No. A well-planned scar fades from red to pale over 12 to 18 months and on the face sits along a line the eye does not read as out of place, but it is permanent.

Where do scars heal best?

The face, which has good blood supply, low tension and natural creases to hide a line in. The trunk, sites over joints and the lower leg are the hardest.

Why is the lower leg difficult?

It is the slowest-healing site on the body — poorer circulation, gravity and swelling all work against it, and wound problems are most likely there. Sutures often stay in two weeks or longer.

Should I stop my blood thinners first?

No — never stop them on your own. They are prescribed for reasons such as stroke or clot prevention, and stopping them for a small skin operation is a much greater risk than the bleeding it might prevent. Most minor skin surgery is done without stopping them. Tell us what you take; any change is made with the doctor who prescribed it.

Does smoking matter?

Yes. Nicotine narrows the small vessels that feed a healing wound, and smokers have more wound breakdown, more infection and worse scars. Even a short pause before and after helps.

What if I scar badly?

Say so before anything is planned, particularly if you have made thick raised spreading scars on the chest, shoulders or earlobes. It changes whether an elective excision is a good idea and what is done afterwards.

When are sutures removed?

Usually 5 to 7 days on the face and 10 to 14 days elsewhere, longer on the lower leg.

What should I avoid while healing?

Stretching the area — no heavy lifting or vigorous exercise, particularly on the trunk and limbs — and picking at scabs or pulling at sutures.

How do I look after the scar afterwards?

Protect it from sun for at least a year once healed; silicone gel and gentle massage help.

When should I call us?

Pain increasing after day two rather than easing, redness spreading from the wound, swelling, heat, pus or smell, fever, the wound opening, a suture out early, or bleeding that does not stop with ten minutes of firm pressure.

When is it an emergency?

Bleeding you cannot control with pressure, a rapidly expanding swelling under the wound, or feeling systemically unwell with fever and shaking chills. Call 000 or go to an emergency department.

When is excision the wrong method?

For a small flat clearly benign lesion removed for appearance only, where a line scar may be worse than the mark; for multiple superficial lesions, which destructive methods handle far better; and for widespread pigment or texture change, which is a resurfacing problem.

Is any of it covered by Medicare?

Excision of a medically indicated lesion generally attracts a rebate — MBS item 45060 covers removal of a skin cancer with flap or graft repair, among other items. Purely cosmetic excision does not. We are not a no-gap provider, so an out-of-pocket cost applies and you are given the expected gap beforehand.

Why does my invoice treat lesions differently?

Because billing can differ lesion by lesion. Three removed cosmetically and one medically at the same appointment is ordinary, not an error. Ask for the invoice itemised so you can see which is which.

Individual results may vary. Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks. Before proceeding you should seek a second opinion from an appropriately qualified health practitioner.

Images on This Page