Acne scar treatments

This page covers the treatments used for acne scarring and what each one is for. For the scar types themselves - ice-pick, boxcar, rolling, hypertrophic and keloid - see acne scars.

The two pages belong together because the single most common reason acne scar treatment disappoints is a mismatch: a treatment aimed at the surface applied to scarring that is not on the surface.

First: is the acne controlled?

Scar treatment on skin that is still actively breaking out is a poor investment. New scars form during the course, and several resurfacing treatments are unsuitable on inflamed skin.

Get the acne under control first. If you have recently taken oral acne medication, say so - resurfacing is usually deferred for a period afterwards because of healing risk.

Also worth establishing before you spend anything: a good proportion of what people call acne scarring is post-inflammatory pigmentation, which is flat, and which fades on its own over months with sun protection. Flat marks and pitted scars are different problems.

How to tell the two apart yourself

Stand at a mirror and look at the marks with light coming from the side rather than straight on. Side lighting casts shadows into anything with depth. A mark that disappears under flat light and reappears under side light has contour - that is a scar. A mark that looks the same under both is flat, and is pigment.

You can also run a fingertip gently over the area with your eyes closed. Pitting and raised scars are palpable; pigmentation is not. This is worth doing before your consultation, because it changes what you are asking for and what it will cost.

Who this is for

Who it is not for, or not yet

Matching treatment to scar

ScarTreatmentWhy
Ice-pick - narrow and deepIndividual treatment of each scar, then resurfacing; excision for the worstDeeper than resurfacing reaches
Boxcar, shallowFractional or ablative laser; skin needlingWithin resurfacing depth
Boxcar, deepResurfacing plus individual treatmentPartial improvement realistic
Rolling - wavy undulationRelease of the tethering bands, then needling or laserThe cause is tethering, not the surface
Volume-loss divotsDermal fillerLost volume needs replacing
Hypertrophic and keloidCortisone injections, siliconeReduction, not resurfacing
Flat dark or red marksSun protection, topicals, peels, light-based treatmentPigment, not contour

Most people have more than one type, which is why a plan usually combines approaches rather than choosing one.

The treatments

Laser resurfacing
CO2 and erbium for deeper resurfacing with more downtime; Fraxel fractionally, with faster recovery and more sessions for the same total effect. The mainstay for boxcar and textural scarring.

Skin needling, often with Factor 4
Collagen stimulation for depressed and textural scarring, in a course four to six weeks apart. A reasonable option for darker skin types, where heat-based resurfacing carries more pigment risk.

Surgical excision
For individual deep ice-pick or boxcar scars - replacing a pit with a fine line, which is usually the better-looking of the two.

Dermal fillers
Lift individual depressed scars where volume has been lost. Temporary; repeated as the filler absorbs.

Cortisone injections
For raised hypertrophic and keloid scars - reducing bulk, redness and itch. A course rather than one injection.

Peels, microdermabrasion and epidermal levelling
For surface texture and the pigmentation that accompanies scarring. Useful adjuncts; not a treatment for contour.

LED, cosmeceutical skincare and depigmenting treatments
Supporting treatments - speeding recovery between sessions, and addressing the pigment component.

Mineral make-up
Cover while the course progresses, and physical sun protection for treated skin.

The process, start to finish

  1. Acne controlled and stable for some months before anything starts.
  2. Assessment - which scar types you have, in what proportion, and how much is pigment rather than contour.
  3. A written plan naming each treatment, what it is addressing, the number of sessions and the total cost.
  4. Baseline photographs, taken with consistent side lighting. You will need them, because change is gradual.
  5. The course, typically several sessions spaced four to six weeks apart over months.
  6. Strict sun protection throughout - this is the part that decides whether you end up better or worse.
  7. Review at six to twelve months, because collagen keeps remodelling well after the last session.

Darker skin types

This deserves its own heading because the calculus genuinely differs. Post-inflammatory hyper-pigmentation is notably more likely in darker skin, and an aggressive resurfacing treatment that produces an excellent contour result can leave pigmentation that is a worse cosmetic problem than the scarring was.

The practical consequences:

If a practitioner proposes aggressive resurfacing on darker skin without raising any of this, that is worth a second opinion.

What results are realistic

Acne scarring improves. It does not disappear. A realistic outcome from a well-chosen course is a substantial reduction in how noticeable the scarring is - not a return to unmarked skin.

Expect several sessions over months, expect to combine approaches, and expect deep ice-pick scarring to improve least. Results continue developing for six to twelve months after treatment as collagen remodels.

Individual results vary with scar type and depth, skin type, age and healing.

How to judge it fairly

Cost over time

Cost depends on which treatments, how many sessions and how large an area, and is quoted after assessment. As at September 2024 and including GST, a skin assessment is $50 and a consultation with a Cosmetic Doctor is $150. Dermal skin treatments start from $130.

Ask for the total for the whole plan before you start, not a per-session price - acne scar work is a course over months, and the difference between three sessions and eight is substantial. Ask also what happens if you want to stop partway, and what a top-up would cost in a few years, since filler in particular is temporary. Not covered by Medicare. We are not a no-gap provider.

What you should leave the consultation with

Risks

See risks and complications.

Expected, and not expected

Expected: redness, swelling, crusting and peeling for days to weeks depending on the treatment, and a period where the skin looks worse before it looks better.

Call us for increasing rather than settling pain, spreading redness or heat, pus, a fever, blistering you were not warned about, a cold sore outbreak in a treated area, or pigmentation that is darkening rather than settling.

Booking

Me Clinic, 4 Burke Road, Malvern East VIC 3145. Phone 1300 852 050 or (03) 9569 3511, or use the online consultation form.

Common questions about acne scar treatments

Why does acne scar treatment disappoint people?

Mismatching - a treatment aimed at the surface applied to scarring that is not on the surface.

Should I treat my scars while I still have acne?

No. New scars form during the course, and several resurfacing treatments are unsuitable on inflamed skin. Control the acne first.

Are my marks actually scars?

A good proportion of what people call acne scarring is post-inflammatory pigmentation, which is flat and fades over months with sun protection.

How can I tell the difference myself?

Look in a mirror with light from the side rather than straight on - side lighting casts shadows into anything with depth. A mark that disappears under flat light and reappears under side light has contour. You can also run a fingertip over it with your eyes closed: scars are palpable, pigment is not.

Why does that matter before I book?

Because it changes what you are asking for and what it will cost. Pigment is treated far more cheaply and gently than contour.

What treats ice-pick scars?

Individual treatment of each scar then resurfacing, with excision for the worst - they are deeper than resurfacing reaches.

What treats rolling scars?

Release of the tethering bands first, then needling or laser. The cause is tethering, not the surface.

What treats raised or keloid scars?

Cortisone injections and silicone, as a course rather than one injection. That is reduction, not resurfacing.

When is excision used?

For individual deep ice-pick or boxcar scars - replacing a pit with a fine line, which is usually the better-looking of the two.

What is the difference between CO2, erbium and Fraxel?

CO2 and erbium resurface more deeply with more downtime; Fraxel works fractionally, with faster recovery and more sessions for the same total effect.

Why might skin needling be chosen over laser?

It is a reasonable option for darker skin types, where heat-based resurfacing carries more pigment risk.

Does my skin type change the plan?

Yes, meaningfully. Post-inflammatory hyper-pigmentation is notably more likely in darker skin, so treatments tend to be more conservative and more numerous rather than fewer and stronger, preparation and sun avoidance matter more, and a test patch is reasonable to ask for.

What if aggressive resurfacing is proposed on darker skin without that discussion?

That is worth a second opinion.

Will my scars go away?

No. Acne scarring improves; it does not disappear. A realistic outcome is a substantial reduction in how noticeable it is, not a return to unmarked skin.

Which scars improve least?

Deep ice-pick scarring.

How long does the course take?

Several sessions over months, typically four to six weeks apart, combining approaches.

When can I judge the result?

Not before six months. Results continue developing for six to twelve months after treatment as collagen remodels.

How should I judge it fairly?

Photograph in identical side lighting without make-up before and at each review, and judge the overall impression at conversational distance rather than in a magnifying mirror at 10cm.

Is it normal for some scars to improve more than others?

Yes, in the same face. That is not a failed treatment.

What does it cost?

It depends on which treatments, how many sessions and how large an area, and is quoted after assessment. A skin assessment is $50 and a Cosmetic Doctor consultation $150, both including GST as at September 2024; dermal skin treatments start from $130.

What should I ask about cost?

The total for the whole plan rather than a per-session price, what happens if you stop partway, and what a top-up costs in a few years - filler in particular is temporary.

What are the risks?

Redness, swelling, crusting and peeling; post-inflammatory hyper-pigmentation, notably more likely in darker skin; hypo-pigmentation which can be permanent; infection including cold sore reactivation after facial resurfacing; new or worsened scarring particularly with aggressive treatment or keloid-prone skin; skin thinning or dimpling after cortisone; and lumps, asymmetry or vascular complications after filler.

When should I call us?

For increasing rather than settling pain, spreading redness or heat, pus, a fever, unexpected blistering, a cold sore outbreak in a treated area, or pigmentation darkening rather than settling.

I have taken oral acne medication. Can I start now?

Say so - resurfacing is usually deferred for a period afterwards because of healing risk.

Individual results may vary. Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks. Before proceeding you should seek a second opinion from an appropriately qualified health practitioner.

Images on This Page