Scars

A scar is the tissue the body lays down to close a wound. It is a repair, not a replacement: scar tissue is made of collagen arranged differently from normal skin, which is why scars have a different colour, texture and flexibility from the skin around them.

Scars can be improved. They cannot be erased. That is the honest starting point for this page, and any treatment discussion that does not begin there is not being straight with you.

Types of scar

Flat and pale (mature) scars

The usual outcome of a well-healed wound. Often pink or red at first, settling to pale over 12 to 18 months.

Hypertrophic scars

Raised, red and firm, but staying within the boundary of the original wound. Often improve slowly over a year or two.

Keloid scars

Raised scars that grow beyond the original wound, sometimes considerably. More common in darker skin and on the chest, shoulders, upper back and earlobes. Keloids are prone to recurrence after treatment - including after surgical removal, which can produce a larger keloid than the one removed. Anyone with a keloid tendency should say so before any elective procedure.

Atrophic scars

Depressed or pitted scars, where tissue was lost. Common after acne and chickenpox. See acne scars.

Contracture scars

Tight scars, usually after a burn, that can restrict movement. These are a functional problem and usually a surgical one.

Stretch marks (striae)

Scars from rapid stretching of the skin - growth, pregnancy, weight change. Red or purple when new, silvery-white when mature. Newer marks respond better than older ones.

What determines how a scar turns out

Most of that list is decided at the time of the wound rather than afterwards, which is why what you do in the first months matters more than what you can buy later.

Timing

Scars change for a long time. A scar at six weeks is not the scar you will have at eighteen months - most continue to flatten and fade well into a second year.

That has a practical consequence: surgical revision is usually deferred until a scar has matured, generally 12 months or more, because operating on an active scar can produce a worse one. Non-surgical measures - silicone, massage, sun protection - are started early, because that is when they do most.

What to do, and when

StageWhat matters
While the wound is openKeep it clean, avoid tension, do not smoke, follow the dressing instructions
Once fully closedStart silicone, start massage, start sunscreen on the scar
Months 1-6Continue consistently. This is when non-surgical measures do most of their work
Months 6-12Cortisone for a raised scar; vascular laser for persistent redness
12 months+Assess for revision, if it is still bothering you

The most common mistake is doing nothing for a year and then seeking treatment. The cheap measures work best early, and by the time a scar has matured the easy gains have been missed.

Treatments

Silicone gel and sheeting

The best-evidenced non-invasive measure for raised scars. Used consistently over months.

Massage and moisturising

Started once the wound is fully closed, helps soften and flatten a scar.

Sun protection

A new scar exposed to sun can pigment permanently. Sunscreen on the scar for at least a year is one of the cheapest and most effective things you can do.

Cortisone injections

Used for hypertrophic and keloid scars to reduce bulk, itch and redness. Usually a series rather than one injection. See cortisone injections.

Skin needling

Stimulates collagen; used mainly for depressed and textural scarring, in a course. See skin needling.

Laser

Fractional and resurfacing lasers improve texture in depressed scars; vascular lasers reduce redness in new and hypertrophic scars. See laser treatments.

Peels and microdermabrasion

For superficial texture and pigmentation associated with scarring.

Surgical revision

Re-excising a scar to place it better, reduce tension or narrow it - trading an existing scar for a different one, which is only worth doing where the new one will be meaningfully better. Deferred until the scar has matured.

Matching treatment to scar

ScarUsual approach
New, red, flatSilicone, massage, sun protection - and time
Raised, within the wound boundarySilicone, cortisone injections
Keloid, beyond the boundaryCortisone, silicone - and caution with surgery
Depressed or pittedNeedling, fractional laser, filler
Persistently redVascular laser
Wide, or badly placedSurgical revision, after 12 months
Tight, restricting movementSurgical - a functional problem
Stretch marks, newNeedling, laser - better response than mature ones

Who this is for, and who it is not

What results are realistic

A well-chosen treatment makes a scar flatter, paler, softer or less obvious in texture. It does not make it disappear, and a scar remains findable if you look for it.

Individual results vary with the scar, the site, your skin type and how you heal. Expect months rather than weeks, and expect the scar to keep changing on its own alongside whatever treatment is done.

Cost over time

Cost depends on the scar, the treatment and the number of sessions, and is quoted after assessment. As at September 2024 and including GST, a skin assessment is $50, a consultation with a Cosmetic Doctor is $150 and a consultation with a Specialist Plastic Surgeon is $350. Dermal skin treatments start from $130.

Worth knowing: the two most effective measures for a new scar - silicone and sunscreen - are the cheapest things on the page, and both are bought rather than booked. Ask what a full course costs before starting anything more involved, and ask what improvement is realistic for your scar specifically.

Cosmetic scar treatment is not covered by Medicare. Revision of a scar causing a functional problem may attract a rebate. We are not a no-gap provider.

What you should leave with

Risks

See risks and complications.

Expected, and not expected

Expected: a new scar being pink, firm and slightly raised for months before softening; redness after laser; and gradual change over a year or more.

Call us for a scar that is growing, spreading beyond its original boundary, becoming painful or intensely itchy, or for spreading redness, pus or a fever after a procedure.

Booking

Me Clinic, 4 Burke Road, Malvern East VIC 3145. Phone 1300 852 050 or (03) 9569 3511, or use the online consultation form.

Common questions about scars

What is a scar?

The tissue the body lays down to close a wound - a repair rather than a replacement. Scar tissue is collagen arranged differently from normal skin, which is why it has a different colour, texture and flexibility.

Can a scar be removed?

No. Scars can be improved but not erased, and any treatment discussion that does not begin there is not being straight with you.

What is the difference between hypertrophic and keloid?

A hypertrophic scar stays within the boundary of the original wound; a keloid grows beyond it, sometimes considerably.

Why do keloids need special caution?

They are prone to recurrence after treatment, including after surgical removal - which can produce a larger keloid than the one removed.

Should I mention a keloid tendency before a procedure?

Yes, before any elective procedure. It changes what is safe.

What determines how a scar turns out?

How the wound was made and closed, where it is, its direction relative to natural creases, tension across it, your genetics and skin type, your age, and whether there was infection, wound separation, smoking or sun exposure.

Which sites scar worst?

The chest, shoulders and back. The eyelid and face generally scar well.

How long does a scar keep changing?

A long time. A scar at six weeks is not the scar you will have at eighteen months - most continue to flatten and fade well into a second year.

When can a scar be revised surgically?

Usually not before 12 months, because operating on an active scar can produce a worse one.

What should I start early?

Silicone, massage and sun protection, once the wound is fully closed. That is when they do most.

What is the most common mistake?

Doing nothing for a year and then seeking treatment. The cheap measures work best early, and by the time a scar has matured the easy gains have been missed.

Why does sun protection matter for a scar?

A new scar exposed to sun can pigment permanently. Sunscreen on the scar for at least a year is one of the cheapest and most effective things you can do.

What is the best-evidenced non-invasive measure?

Silicone gel and sheeting, for raised scars, used consistently over months.

What treats a raised scar?

Silicone and cortisone injections, usually as a series rather than one injection.

What treats a depressed scar?

Needling, fractional laser and filler.

What treats persistent redness?

Vascular laser.

What is surgical revision actually doing?

Trading an existing scar for a different one - by placing it better, reducing tension or narrowing it. Only worth doing where the new one will be meaningfully better.

Do stretch marks respond?

Newer ones respond better than older ones. Mature silvery-white marks respond least of all.

What about a tight scar restricting movement?

That is a functional problem and usually a surgical one, rather than a cosmetic treatment.

What results should I expect?

Flatter, paler, softer or less obvious. Not gone - a scar remains findable if you look for it.

Which features respond best?

Redness responds well and raised scars flatten substantially. Depressed scars improve partially, keloids improve but recur readily, and mature stretch marks respond least.

What does it cost?

It depends on the scar, the treatment and the number of sessions. A skin assessment is $50, a Cosmetic Doctor consultation $150 and a Specialist Plastic Surgeon consultation $350, all including GST as at September 2024; dermal skin treatments start from $130.

What is the cheapest effective thing I can do?

Silicone and sunscreen on a new scar. Both are bought rather than booked, and they are the two most effective measures early.

Is any of it covered by Medicare?

Cosmetic scar treatment is not. Revision of a scar causing a functional problem may attract a rebate. We are not a no-gap provider.

What are the risks?

A worse scar including a larger keloid after excision; skin thinning, dimpling or pigment loss at a cortisone site; pigment change that can persist; redness, swelling, crusting and peeling after laser or needling; infection; delayed healing or wound separation after revision; incomplete improvement and recurrence; and reaction to local anaesthetic.

When should I call us?

For a scar that is growing, spreading beyond its original boundary, becoming painful or intensely itchy, or for spreading redness, pus or a fever after a procedure.

Individual results may vary. Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks. Before proceeding you should seek a second opinion from an appropriately qualified health practitioner.

Images on This Page