Mole removal and scarring

Start from the honest position: every method of removing a mole leaves some mark. The question is not whether there will be a mark, but what kind, how visible, and whether the trade is worth it for the lesion you have.

No treatment can guarantee a scar-free result. Anyone telling you otherwise is overselling.

What each method leaves behind

Laser removal

Lasers used for flat pigmented lesions include IPL, KTP and Nd:YAG. They target and destroy the pigmented tissue, and the heat also seals the treated area. There is no incision.

Healing and discomfort vary between individuals. Many people are left with a flat mark that lightens toward their normal skin tone over months. Some are left with a persistent lighter or darker patch. Visible scarring is uncommon but possible.

Radiofrequency (RF) removal

Radiofrequency energy is directed at the lesion, targeting the tissue precisely while sparing surrounding skin. No cutting, no sutures. Recovery varies - some people have essentially no downtime, others take longer. The degree of marking varies too, and returning to normal activity immediately is not right for everyone.

Cryotherapy

Liquid nitrogen freezes the lesion; the treated skin dies and sheds over a period that varies between individuals. A change in skin tone at the site is common - typically a lighter patch, which can persist.

Shave excision

A scalpel or radiofrequency device removes a raised lesion level with the skin. Healing takes several weeks. A small flat scar is common, and its visibility varies.

Ellipse excision

The most invasive option, used for suspicious lesions and those unsuitable for laser or shave removal. The whole lesion is removed and the wound closed with dissolvable or non-dissolvable sutures. A thin line scar remains permanently.

This is a deliberate trade: excision produces the most scarring and is the only method that produces a diagnosis. Where a lesion needs to be identified, the scar is the price of knowing.

The trade, laid out

MethodUsual markPermanent?Diagnosis?
LaserFlat patch, lightening over monthsSometimes a persistent colour changeNo
RadiofrequencyFlat patch, variableColour change can persistNo
CryotherapyOften a lighter patchFrequently yesNo
Shave excisionSmall flat scarYes, usually subtleYes
Ellipse excisionThin line scarYes, permanentlyYes, definitive

Read the last two columns together. For a lesion that needs identifying, the bottom row is the right answer even though it is the worst row for scarring.

Would the mark bother you more than the mole?

This is the question worth sitting with before a purely cosmetic removal, because for some lesions the honest answer is yes.

It is more likely to be yes when:

It is more likely to be no when the mole is raised, catches on things, is on a site that heals well like much of the face, and genuinely bothers you day to day.

A practitioner who says "I would leave that one" is doing their job, not turning down work.

What you cannot control

What you can control

The first item on that list does more than the rest combined, and it is free.

How scars behave over time

A new scar is red or pink and firm. Over 12 to 18 months it typically flattens, softens and fades toward the surrounding skin tone. That maturation is why a scar should not be judged at six weeks.

Some scars do not follow that course. Hypertrophic scars stay raised within the original wound; keloid scars extend beyond it. Both are more likely in certain sites and in people prone to them, and both can be treated - see scars and cortisone injections.

A rough timeline

WhenWhat it looks like
Week 1-2Scab, or sutures in place; red and tender
Week 2-6Fresh pink skin, often slightly raised. Looks worse than the final result
Months 2-6Still pink and firm. This is the stage people worry
Months 6-12Flattening, softening, fading
12-18 monthsMature. This is the scar you keep

If you are at month three and unhappy, that is normal and it is too early. If you are at month three and the scar is growing, thickening, spreading beyond the original wound, or intensely itchy, that is different - call.

Before your procedure

A Me Clinic doctor provides a skin consultation before any procedure. You may also need your moles checked by your own doctor first, so that the specific lesion can be safely removed by the method proposed.

At that consultation:

Facial mole removal and removal elsewhere on the body are typically performed under local anaesthetic. Complexity varies with the lesion and site.

The question to ask, phrased usefully

Not "will it scar" - the answer is yes. Ask instead: "On my skin, at this site, with this method, what will this look like at twelve months?"

A practitioner who can answer that specifically, and who offers to show you a comparable case, is giving you what you need to decide. A vague reassurance is not an answer.

Aftercare

Expected, and not expected

Expected: a scab or sutures for a week or two, fresh pink skin that looks worse than the final result, firmness for months, and gradual flattening and fading over a year or more.

Call us for increasing rather than settling pain, spreading redness or heat, pus or a bad smell, a fever, a wound edge that separates, bleeding that does not stop with ten minutes of firm pressure, or a scar that is growing, thickening or spreading beyond the original wound.

If you are unhappy with a scar

Cost

Cost depends on the lesion, the method and the site, and is quoted at consultation. As at September 2024 and including GST, a mole removal consultation is $150. See mole removal costs.

Ask whether follow-up and suture removal are included, and what a scar treatment or revision would cost if one were wanted later. Cosmetic removal is not covered by Medicare; medically indicated removal may attract a rebate. We are not a no-gap provider.

What you should leave with

Booking

Me Clinic, 4 Burke Road, Malvern East VIC 3145. Phone 1300 852 050 or (03) 9569 3511, or use the online consultation form.

Common questions about mole removal and scarring

Will mole removal leave a scar?

Every method leaves some mark. The question is what kind, how visible, and whether the trade is worth it for the lesion you have.

Can a scar-free result be guaranteed?

No. Anyone telling you otherwise is overselling.

What does laser removal leave?

Often a flat mark that lightens toward your normal skin tone over months. Some people are left with a persistent lighter or darker patch, and visible scarring is uncommon but possible.

What does cryotherapy leave?

A change in skin tone at the site is common - typically a lighter patch, which can persist.

What does excision leave?

A thin line scar, permanently.

Why would anyone choose excision then?

Because it is the only method that produces a diagnosis. Where a lesion needs to be identified, the scar is the price of knowing.

How do I decide between methods?

Read the diagnosis column together with the scarring column. For a lesion that needs identifying, excision is right even though it scars most. For a confidently benign lesion, the gentler methods make sense.

Could the mark bother me more than the mole?

Genuinely, yes, for some lesions - more likely if the mole is large, if you have darker skin, if it is on the chest, shoulders or upper back, if you scar readily, or if the mole is flat and pale and only you notice it.

What if my practitioner suggests leaving it?

That is them doing their job, not turning down work.

What affects scarring that I cannot change?

Your skin and any keloid tendency, which is largely genetic; the site, since chest, shoulders and back scar more visibly while facial skin heals better; the size and depth of the lesion; and which method is clinically appropriate.

What can I actually control?

Sun protection above all, not picking the scab, following wound care instructions, not smoking, avoiding tension on the wound, and using silicone and massage once closed where advised.

Which of those matters most?

Sun protection. It does more than the rest combined, and it is free. Cover the site and use sunscreen on it for months, not weeks.

What happens if I pick the scab?

It heals more slowly and scars worse.

How does a scar change over time?

A new scar is red or pink and firm, and over 12 to 18 months typically flattens, softens and fades toward the surrounding skin tone.

When should I judge it?

Not at six weeks, and not at three months. Twelve to eighteen months is when you are looking at the scar you keep.

I am three months in and unhappy. Is that normal?

Yes, and it is too early. Months two to six is the stage people worry - still pink and firm.

When is it not just normal healing?

If the scar is growing, thickening, spreading beyond the original wound, or intensely itchy. Call about that.

What is the difference between hypertrophic and keloid?

Hypertrophic scars stay raised within the original wound; keloid scars extend beyond it. Both can be treated.

What should I tell my practitioner beforehand?

All medications you take, whether any mole has changed in size, shape or colour, and whether you scar badly or have had a keloid.

What is the best question to ask about scarring?

Not "will it scar" but "on my skin, at this site, with this method, what will this look like at twelve months?" - and ask to see a comparable case.

What if I am unhappy with a scar later?

Wait for maturation before judging; raised scars respond to cortisone and silicone, better started earlier; redness responds to vascular laser; and surgical revision trades your scar for a different one, worth doing only where the new one will be meaningfully better. Say something - a clinic should want to know.

What aftercare is needed?

Keep the site clean, follow the dressing instructions, do not pick the scab, avoid swimming and soaking until healed, avoid stretching the area, protect from sun and then use sunscreen for months, attend for suture removal, and start silicone and massage once fully closed where advised.

What does it cost?

It depends on the lesion, method and site, and is quoted at consultation. A mole removal consultation is $150 including GST as at September 2024. Ask whether follow-up and suture removal are included, and what scar treatment or revision would cost later.

Individual results may vary. Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks. Before proceeding you should seek a second opinion from an appropriately qualified health practitioner.

Images on This Page