Patient stories

You will not find patient stories or testimonials on this site. That is deliberate, and it is worth explaining why - because their absence is a good sign about a clinic, not a gap.

Testimonials are prohibited

Under section 133 of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law, advertising a regulated health service must not use testimonials or purported testimonials about the service or the practitioner.

That covers written patient accounts, quotes, star ratings and reviews used in advertising, video stories, and - since 1 July 2023 - influencer content about cosmetic procedures.

The reason is not squeamishness about praise. It is that one person's outcome tells you almost nothing about yours. Cosmetic results depend on your anatomy, your skin, your age, your healing, your medical history and what you started with. A story from someone whose starting point differed from yours is not evidence about your result - but it is highly persuasive, which is precisely the problem.

Testimonials also select themselves. The person who is delighted writes in. The person whose result disappointed them, or who had a complication, generally does not.

What we show instead

Before and after photographs, in consultation

Photographs of our own patients are shown at your consultation, where cases can be chosen to match your anatomy, your concern and the procedure being proposed - including cases where the result was partial. A website gallery is chosen to impress; a case shown across a desk can be chosen to inform.

See the before and after gallery and how to read before and after images.

Honest limits, stated on every page

Through this site you will find what each procedure cannot do stated as plainly as what it can: scars are permanent, melasma recurs, deep acne scarring improves rather than disappears, fillers are temporary, results vary, and some people are not suitable candidates.

Registration you can verify

Every practitioner is named with their AHPRA registration number, verifiable in a minute at ahpra.gov.au. That is checkable. A story is not.

Prices before you commit

Indicative prices are on the procedure pages, and you get one accurate written quote at consultation.

What to read instead of a story

The pages in this section cover the things a patient story would normally be doing - telling you what it is actually like:

If you want to hear from people who have had a procedure

That is a reasonable thing to want. Places to look that are not clinic advertising:

Ask us at consultation whether we can put you in touch with someone who has had the procedure. Whether that is possible depends entirely on another patient volunteering and consenting - we will not arrange it otherwise, and we will not solicit it.

Booking

Me Clinic, 4 Burke Road, Malvern East VIC 3145. Phone 1300 852 050 or (03) 9569 3511, or use the online consultation form.

What to look at instead, and what each is worth

If stories are off the table, the question becomes what actually carries information about a surgeon and a procedure. Ranked roughly by how much weight it deserves.

SourceWhat it tells youWhat it does not
The AHPRA registerRegistration status, specialty, conditions or undertakings on practiceSkill, judgement, or how the surgeon behaves when something goes wrong
The consultation itselfWhether risks are volunteered or extracted, whether you are told no, whether numbers are written downAnything about technical results
Before-and-after photographsThe kind of change a surgeon aims at, and their aestheticComplication rate, revision rate, durability, or how it felt - and they are a selected set by definition
Published revision and complication ratesThe most useful figure there is, when a clinic will give itHow the figure was counted, unless you ask
A second opinionWhether the plan is the plan, or one surgeon's preferenceLittle - this is close to the highest-value hour you can spend

The questions a story could never have answered anyway

Even where testimonials are permitted, they answer almost none of what a person considering surgery actually needs.

If you do want to hear from someone who has had it done

That is a reasonable thing to want, and there are lawful routes to it.

What we cannot do is put you in touch with a former patient. Arranging that would use one person's experience to promote the service to another, which is the thing section 133 prohibits - and it would require us to disclose that they were a patient at all.

Common questions about patient stories and testimonials

Why are there no patient stories on this site?

Because testimonials about a regulated health service are prohibited in advertising. Their absence is a good sign about a clinic, not a gap.

Which law says so?

Section 133 of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law - advertising a regulated health service must not use testimonials or purported testimonials about the service or the practitioner.

What counts as a testimonial?

Written patient accounts, quotes, star ratings and reviews used in advertising, video stories, and - since 1 July 2023 - influencer content about cosmetic procedures.

Is the rule just squeamishness about praise?

No. It is that one person's outcome tells you almost nothing about yours.

Why not?

Because cosmetic results depend on your anatomy, your skin, your age, your healing, your medical history and what you started with. A story from someone whose starting point differed from yours is not evidence about your result - but it is highly persuasive, which is precisely the problem.

What is selection bias in this context?

Testimonials select themselves. The person who is delighted writes in; the person whose result disappointed them, or who had a complication, generally does not.

Do you show before and after photographs at all?

Yes - photographs of our own patients, at your consultation.

Why show them there rather than online?

Because cases can be chosen to match your anatomy, your concern and the procedure being proposed - including cases where the result was partial. A website gallery is chosen to impress; a case shown across a desk can be chosen to inform.

What do the procedure pages say about limits?

What each procedure cannot do, as plainly as what it can: scars are permanent, melasma recurs, deep acne scarring improves rather than disappears, fillers are temporary, results vary, and some people are not suitable candidates.

How do I check a practitioner?

Every practitioner is named with their AHPRA registration number, verifiable in a minute at ahpra.gov.au. That is checkable; a story is not.

Will I know the price before I commit?

Indicative prices are on the procedure pages, and you get one accurate written quote at consultation.

What should I read instead of a story?

The pages in this section: what a consultation involves, what recovery actually involves, whether a result is realistic for you, the total cost including what is not in the quote, what happens if a result is not what you hoped, deciding not to proceed, and questions worth asking any clinic.

Where can I hear from people who have had a procedure?

Your GP, who has seen where their other patients ended up; a second-opinion consultation with another Specialist Plastic Surgeon; and independent patient support communities, read with the same scepticism about selection bias.

Can the clinic put me in touch with a former patient?

Ask at consultation. Whether it is possible depends entirely on another patient volunteering and consenting - we will not arrange it otherwise, and we will not solicit it.

How do I book?

Phone 1300 852 050 or (03) 9569 3511, or use the online consultation form. Me Clinic, 4 Burke Road, Malvern East VIC 3145.

Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks. Before proceeding you should seek a second opinion from an appropriately qualified health practitioner. Individual results may vary.

Images on This Page