How to remove a mole

Mole removal is a common procedure, and it is straightforward — but the order matters. Assessment comes before removal, every time. The method is chosen after a lesion has been examined, not before.

Surgical warning: Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks. Before proceeding you should seek a second opinion from an appropriately qualified health practitioner.

The rule that governs everything on this page

A pigmented lesion that has not been assessed must not be lasered, frozen or burned off. Destructive methods leave nothing to send to pathology, and they can erase the evidence of an early melanoma while leaving the deeper part of it behind. The lesion appears to be gone; the disease is not.

So the sequence is always:

A practitioner who offers to laser or freeze a mole without examining it properly is doing you a disservice, whatever it costs.

Methods, and what each is actually for

Surgical excision

The lesion is cut out in full, under local anaesthetic, and closed with sutures. The tissue goes to pathology. This is the method for anything suspicious, anything changing, and anything where a definite diagnosis is needed. It leaves a linear scar longer than the mole itself, because the skin has to be closed neatly.

Radiofrequency shave

A fine radiofrequency handpiece removes a raised lesion level with the surrounding skin and seals the base as it goes, so bleeding is minimal. It suits raised, clearly benign lesions — skin tags, dermal naevi, some seborrhoeic keratoses. Tissue can still be sent for pathology. Healing is usually a small scab that separates within about a week, leaving a flat mark that fades over months. Because it removes only what sits above the skin surface, any pigment cells deeper in the skin remain, and colour can return — which is one reason it is not used where there is any diagnostic doubt.

Cryotherapy

Liquid nitrogen destroys tissue by freezing. It is appropriate for certain confidently diagnosed benign lesions such as skin tags, seborrhoeic keratoses and solar keratoses. It is not a treatment for pigmented moles: it destroys the tissue, so nothing can be examined. It commonly leaves a pale mark, particularly on darker skin, and sometimes a blister first.

Laser

Vascular and pigment lasers treat specific targets — broken capillaries, sun-induced pigmentation, some flat benign marks. Like cryotherapy, laser destroys tissue rather than removing it for examination, so it has no role in treating a mole that has not been confidently assessed as benign.

Why the scar is three times longer than the mole

The most common surprise after an excision, and it is geometry rather than anyone being heavy-handed.

If you cut a circle out of skin and pull the edges together, the skin bunches at each end into a small standing cone — a raised pucker surgeons call a dog ear. To close a round defect flat, the cut has to be shaped as an ellipse, conventionally about three times as long as it is wide, so that the angles at each end are shallow enough for the skin to lie down.

The arithmetic follows directly:

This is why asking your surgeon to draw the line before you consent is worth doing, particularly on the face, chest or shoulder. The chest and shoulders are also where scars are most likely to widen or thicken, which is a reason to think twice about removing a harmless mole there purely for appearance.

And the honest framing for a cosmetic removal: you are exchanging a small round mark for a longer straight one. For a lesion that catches on clothing or a razor, or one that concerns you, that is usually a good trade. For a flat mole that only you notice, it sometimes is not.

What happens to the tissue, and how to read the report

Anything sent to pathology produces a written report, usually within about a week. It goes to the doctor who removed the lesion, and you are entitled to a copy and to have it explained. The vocabulary is small and worth knowing.

The one rule about results

No news is not good news. Reports are occasionally misfiled, sent to the wrong address, or lost when someone changes practice. Before you leave, ask when the result is expected, who will contact you and how — then, if you have not heard by that date, ring and ask. It takes two minutes and it is the single most useful thing a patient does in this whole process.

Ask for a copy of the report for your own records, and keep it. If a lesion is ever removed from the same area again, that first report matters.

Scarring

Every removal leaves a mark. Excision leaves a line; shave and destructive methods usually leave a flat pale or pink patch. Scars look their worst at around six to eight weeks and improve for a year or more. Keep the area out of the sun or under high-SPF sunscreen for at least twelve months — sun on a healing scar causes lasting darkening. See mole removal and scarring.

Checking your own skin: ABCDE

Australia has among the highest rates of melanoma in the world, and early detection is what changes outcomes. Check your skin regularly, and ask someone to check your back and scalp.

Also use the “ugly duckling” idea: most of your moles resemble each other, and the one that stands out from the rest deserves a look. Some melanomas lack pigment altogether and appear pink or skin-coloured, so a new, firm, growing lump warrants attention even if it is not brown. Check places you do not normally look — soles, between toes, under nails, scalp, and genital skin.

Photographing a mole so the photographs are actually useful

Change over time is the most reliable signal there is, and it is impossible to judge from memory. A short monthly routine makes it objective.

  1. Put something for scale in the frame — a ruler, or a coin of the same denomination every time. Without it, a photograph cannot show size change.
  2. Same light, same place. Daylight near a window, not a flash, which flattens colour and hides texture.
  3. Turn off filters and beauty mode. They are on by default on many phones and they smooth exactly the border and colour detail that matters.
  4. Two shots: one from about 30 cm showing the lesion and its neighbours, one closer for detail.
  5. Note the location in the filename or a note — “left shoulder blade, outer”. Backs are hard to map later.
  6. Monthly, on a set date. Compare the oldest to the newest, not last month to this month.

Take the series to your appointment. It is genuinely useful evidence — but a photograph is not a diagnosis, and nobody, including us, can assess a lesion from one.

Higher risk

Be more vigilant, and consider regular skin checks, if you have fair skin that burns easily, many moles, atypical (dysplastic) moles, a personal or family history of melanoma, a history of sunburn or solarium use, or long-term outdoor work.

Two further groups worth naming: anyone taking long-term immunosuppressive medication, including after an organ transplant, and anyone who has already had a skin cancer — having had one is among the strongest predictors of having another.

Where to go

Me Clinic doctors assess and remove skin lesions, and anything removed with any question over it goes to pathology. We do not have a dermatologist on staff. Where specialist dermatological assessment or management of a skin cancer is required, we refer you — to a dermatologist, a skin cancer clinic, or a plastic surgeon, as appropriate. Your GP can also refer you directly.

If something on your skin is changing, do not wait for a cosmetic appointment. See your GP.

Costs and booking

Mole removal consultation $150, including GST, as at September 2024. The cost of removal depends on the lesion, the method and the number treated, and you receive a written quote after assessment. Where a lesion is removed as a skin cancer with flap or graft repair, an MBS item number may apply (for example 45060) — ask for the item number and check the rebate with Medicare and your fund. We are not a no-gap provider.

Me Clinic, 4 Burke Road, Malvern East VIC 3145. Phone 1300 852 050 or (03) 9569 3511, or use the consultation form. Note that no one can diagnose a skin lesion from a photograph — an online enquiry is a way to book, not a way to be assessed.

Common questions about mole removal

What is the rule about removing moles?

Assessment comes before removal, every time. A pigmented lesion that has not been assessed must not be lasered, frozen or burned off.

Why does that matter so much?

Destructive methods leave nothing to send to pathology, and can erase the evidence of an early melanoma while leaving the deeper part behind. The lesion looks gone; the disease is not.

What are the removal methods?

Surgical excision, radiofrequency shave, cryotherapy and laser — and only the first two produce tissue that can be examined.

When is excision used?

For anything suspicious, anything changing, and anything where a definite diagnosis is needed.

Why can colour come back after a shave removal?

Because a shave removes only what sits above the skin surface, and pigment cells deeper in the skin remain.

Why is the scar longer than the mole?

Because a round hole closed directly puckers at each end. To close flat, the cut is shaped as an ellipse about three times as long as it is wide.

How long will my scar be?

A 6 mm mole with a small margin needs an ellipse of roughly 20 to 25 mm; a 10 mm lesion produces 35 mm or more.

Can I see where the cut will go?

Yes — ask your surgeon to draw the line before you consent, particularly on the face, chest or shoulder.

Where do scars behave worst?

The chest and shoulders, where scars are more likely to widen or thicken. That is a reason to think twice about removing a harmless mole there purely for appearance.

Is cosmetic removal worth it?

You are exchanging a small round mark for a longer straight one. For a lesion that catches on clothing or a razor, or one that worries you, that is usually a good trade.

How long do pathology results take?

Usually about a week. The report goes to the doctor who removed the lesion, and you are entitled to a copy and to have it explained.

What do the words on the report mean?

Benign naevus is an ordinary mole; dysplastic or atypical means irregular features, graded mild to severe; seborrhoeic keratosis is a harmless growth; basal and squamous cell carcinoma are skin cancers; melanoma reports include a Breslow thickness in millimetres.

What is the most important line?

The margins. “Clear” means normal tissue surrounded the lesion; “involved” means some was left behind and further surgery is usually recommended.

What if I do not hear anything?

No news is not good news. Ask when the result is expected, who will contact you and how — then ring if you have not heard by that date.

Should I keep the report?

Yes. If a lesion is ever removed from the same area again, the first report matters.

What is the ABCDE check?

Asymmetry, Border irregularity, Colour variation, Diameter over about 6 mm, and Evolving — any change in size, shape, colour or elevation, or new itching, bleeding or crusting.

What is the ugly duckling sign?

Most of your moles resemble each other. The one that stands out from the rest deserves a look.

Can a melanoma be colourless?

Yes. Some lack pigment and appear pink or skin-coloured, so a new firm growing lump warrants attention even if it is not brown.

Where do people forget to look?

Soles, between the toes, under nails, the scalp and genital skin — and the back, which needs someone else.

How should I photograph a mole?

With a ruler or the same coin for scale, in daylight not flash, with filters and beauty mode off, one shot from about 30 cm and one closer, labelled with the location, monthly on a set date.

Can a photo be used to diagnose it?

No. A photograph series is useful evidence of change, but nobody can assess a lesion from one.

Who is at higher risk?

People with fair skin that burns, many moles, atypical moles, a personal or family history of melanoma, sunburn or solarium history, outdoor work, long-term immunosuppression, or a previous skin cancer.

Does Me Clinic have a dermatologist?

No. Where specialist dermatological assessment or skin cancer management is required, we refer you, and your GP can also refer you directly.

What does it cost?

A mole removal consultation is $150 including GST as at September 2024, with removal quoted in writing after assessment. Where a skin cancer is removed with flap or graft repair, an MBS item such as 45060 may apply.

Individual results may vary. Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks. Before proceeding you should seek a second opinion from an appropriately qualified health practitioner.

Images on This Page