The five running-cost budgets, and how each one is built
A novated lease deduction has a finance component and five budgets. The finance component is arithmetic — a rate, a term, an amount, a residual. The budgets are estimates, and estimates are where quotes diverge from each other and from reality.
This page takes the five one at a time: what drives each number, what a reasonable figure looks like, and the specific way each one can be set too low.
The reference point throughout is the sample 60-month estimate Vehicle Solutions issues, built on a $65,000 vehicle at 15,000 km a year.
Why the budgets decide whether a quote is honest
Lower any of these five and three things happen at once: the deduction falls, the quoted cost to your take-home pay falls, and the quote looks more competitive than the one beside it.
Nothing about the car has changed. The shortfall simply moves — out of the budget and into your after-tax income, at whatever moment the cost actually lands.
So the useful comparison between two quotes is not the weekly figure. It is the five assumptions underneath it, and whether each is defensible for how you actually drive. Comparing novated leasing quotes covers the comparison itself; this page is about the inputs.
1. Fuel or charging
What drives it: your annual distance, the vehicle's real-world consumption, and the price you pay per litre or per kilowatt-hour.
On the sample estimate: $600 a year, $23.08 a fortnight including GST.
How it goes wrong: the distance. A budget built on 15,000 km a year is simply wrong for someone driving 25,000, and the error compounds across every other usage-driven line below. Manufacturer consumption figures are also optimistic against real driving.
What to ask: what annual distance is this built on, and what consumption and fuel price were assumed? If you drive an electric car and charge at home, ask how home charging is treated, because it is not a fuel-card transaction.
2. Tyres
What drives it: distance again, tyre size and specification, and how the car is driven. Large-diameter and performance tyres cost multiples of ordinary ones.
On the sample estimate: $450 a year, $17.31 a fortnight including GST.
How it goes wrong: the replacement interval. A budget that assumes one set over a long term, on a car whose tyres will not last that far, is the single most common under-build. The budget covers replacement tyres; it does not cover a kerbed rim or a puncture outside normal wear.
What to ask: how many sets over the term, at what price per tyre, for the actual size fitted to the car I am buying.
3. Scheduled servicing
What drives it: the manufacturer's service schedule, which is set by time, distance or whichever comes first, and the make's own pricing.
On the sample estimate: $300 a year, $11.54 a fortnight including GST.
How it goes wrong: two ways. A budget built on capped-price servicing that runs out partway through the term, and a budget that quietly assumes the cheaper interval when your distance will trigger the dearer one.
Note the word scheduled. Anything outside the manufacturer's schedule is not covered, and nor is an unscheduled repair that is not a warranty claim. The finance terms also require repairs to be carried out by qualified personnel.
What to ask: which service schedule, how many services across the term, and whether capped-price servicing covers all of them.
4. Registration and CTP
What drives it: your state, the vehicle class and the CTP premium.
On the sample estimate: $750 a year, $28.85 a fortnight. Note this is the one line where the figures excluding and including GST are the same, because registration and CTP are not taxed the way the other components are.
How it goes wrong: rarely, and by small amounts. This is the most predictable of the five because it is set by a government schedule rather than by usage.
What to ask: which state it has been built on, if you have moved or are about to.
5. Comprehensive insurance
What drives it: the vehicle, your age and history, your address, your excess, and the insurer you choose.
On the sample estimate: $1,500 a year, $57.69 a fortnight including GST.
How it goes wrong: a quote built on a notional premium rather than your actual one. A young driver, a high-value vehicle or a poor claims history can move this line substantially.
The important point: Vehicle Solutions does not sell insurance. There is no insurer panel and no add-on product. You arrange your own policy with the insurer you choose, and the premium is budgeted and paid from your packaging account.
Two conditions come from the finance lease rather than from us. You must hold comprehensive cover for the vehicle's current market value for the whole term, and the financier must approve the insurer and be noted on the policy as owner and first loss payee.
What to ask: get a real quote from your own insurer for the exact vehicle, and have that figure used rather than an estimate.
What sits outside all five
Your insurance excess after a claim. Fines and tolls. Car washes, detailing and cosmetic work. Unscheduled repairs. Anything beyond the manufacturer's scheduled servicing. All of it is after-tax money.
Alongside the five budgets, the deduction also carries the finance lease itself and the $395 annual administration fee.
Checking the budgets while the lease runs
You get online secure access to your packaging account, showing the credits from your employer's deductions, the payments made on your behalf and the balance held.
That is where a drifting budget shows up first. The time to raise it is at a review, not at the end of the term when the shortfall has already accumulated.
Frequently asked questions
Which of the five budgets is most often set too low?
Tyres, usually by assuming too few sets across the term, followed by fuel through an optimistic distance assumption.
Does a lower deduction mean a better deal?
Not on its own. It may simply mean the budgets have been built smaller, which moves cost rather than removing it.
What distance should I nominate?
Your real one. Nominating low makes the quote look better and guarantees a shortfall.
Are the budgets guaranteed?
No. They are estimates, and a shortfall in any category is funded from your after-tax income.
How is home charging handled for an electric car?
Ask, because it is not a fuel-card transaction. The treatment should be stated before you sign.
Does the servicing budget cover a breakdown?
No. It covers the manufacturer's scheduled servicing only.
Who picks the tyres?
You do, within the specification for the vehicle. The budget is built on a price and a number of sets, so an upgrade comes from your own money.
Should the insurance line be an estimate or my own quote?
Your own quote, for the exact vehicle. An estimated premium is the easiest of the five budgets to get badly wrong, particularly for a young driver.
Why does the registration line show the same figure with and without GST?
Because registration and CTP are not subject to GST in the way the other budget components are.
Which of the five is the most predictable?
Registration and CTP, because a government schedule sets it rather than how far or how hard you drive.
Can the budgets be changed mid-lease?
Yes, at a review, if your real costs differ from the assumptions. The finance component cannot change.
How do I check whether a quote's assumptions are reasonable?
Ask for all five written out as annual figures with the distance, the number of services and the number of tyre sets stated. Call (08) 8338 4427.
Related pages
- Comparing novated leasing quotes
- How novated leasing works
- Residual value
- Salary packaging a vehicle
- Novated lease calculator
- Frequently asked questions
Images on This Page
-
https://vehiclesolutions.com.au/images/vsa-logo-white.svg
Vehicle Solutions Australia logo
-
https://vehiclesolutions.com.au/storage/blog-posts/106/122609/car-novated-lease.jpg
(no alt text)