Saving money on a novated lease: the other side of the ledger
Pages about saving money list the savings. This one lists everything on the debit side, in full, with the figures where figures exist.
That is not an argument against novated leasing. It is the only way to know whether your own arrangement actually saves you anything, because a saving is a net figure and you cannot net off a list you have never seen.
The savings themselves are set out on do novated leases save you money?. Here is what runs the other way.
1. Interest
You are financing a car, so there is interest, and it is usually the largest single cost after the vehicle itself.
The rate is not printed on a Vehicle Solutions quote, which shows the payments and the amount financed instead. Ask for it explicitly. Without it you cannot compare the finance component against any other offer, and you cannot tell how much of your deduction is cost rather than capital.
Overdue amounts attract more. The financier's terms charge interest on a late amount at the implicit rate used to calculate the rentals plus an additional 4% a year, accruing daily.
2. The administration fee
Vehicle Solutions charges $395 a year, and no other fee. It appears as a budget line in the quote — $15.19 a fortnight including GST on the sample estimate.
That is the whole of what the packager charges. It is a small number against a lease, and it is worth knowing precisely because other debits below are larger and less visible.
3. Commission
Vehicle Solutions is paid a commission by the financier, calculated on the amount of finance written each month.
It is not a charge to you and it does not appear on your quote. It is disclosed here because it is a real economic interest in the size and existence of the lease, and you are entitled to know it when you are weighing advice.
A financier is chosen on best rate from three: Pepper Asset Finance, Metro Finance and Angle Finance.
4. The financier's fees
Separate from the packager's fee, the financier has its own schedule. From the Pepper finance lease terms:
| Fee | Amount |
|---|---|
| Late payment, if an instalment is more than 5 days late | $35.00 |
| Dishonour of a payment instruction | $5.00 |
| Account closing | $20.00 |
| Information fee | $0.00 |
| Payment handling by BPAY, EFT or direct deposit | $0.00 |
| Variation at your request | at cost |
| Asset inspection, where required | at cost |
| Asset valuation, where required | at cost |
Metro Finance and Angle Finance set their own. Ask for the schedule that applies to the financier you are actually written with.
5. The residual
The largest single debit at the end, and the one people most often leave out of the comparison.
The residual is a percentage of the amount financed, falling due as a lump sum: 65.63% at one year down to 28.13% at five, which are the ATO minimums Vehicle Solutions applies. On the sample 60-month estimate it is $18,240.90 including GST.
Three things to be clear about:
- You remain personally liable for the residual under the novation agreement, even though the rest of the lease is novated to your employer.
- If you return the vehicle instead, the financier sells it and you pay the shortfall between the sale proceeds and the residual on demand.
- You do not build equity during the term. Residual value explains why that is structural rather than a quirk.
6. The reportable fringe benefits amount
This one costs real money and never appears in a quote.
Where your reportable fringe benefits exceed $2,000 in taxable value in an FBT year, the grossed-up figure goes on your income statement. It is not taxed as income, but it is counted in income tests — study and training loan repayments, family assistance, child support, the Medicare levy surcharge and several others.
It applies to exempt electric cars too. The FBT exemption removes the tax, not the reporting.
For someone with a study loan, this can absorb a meaningful share of the saving. Ask payroll for the projected figure before you commit, not after.
7. Budget shortfalls
The running-cost budgets are assumptions, not guarantees.
Lower the fuel, tyre or servicing assumptions and the deduction falls and the quote looks better. The car has not become cheaper. The shortfall lands on you, out of after-tax income, at whatever moment the tyres actually wear out.
Test the assumptions against your real distance before you compare two quotes. Comparing novated leasing quotes sets out how.
8. What the package never covers
Funded entirely from your after-tax income: your insurance excess, fines and tolls, car washes and detailing, cosmetic work, unscheduled repairs outside warranty and the servicing budget, and anything beyond the manufacturer's scheduled servicing.
Reimbursements for covered expenses you have paid yourself require tax invoices.
9. Ending the lease early
The expensive one, and the reason to get the term right at the start.
You can terminate by giving not less than 14 days' written notice expiring on a payment date. The notice is irrevocable. You may ask for an estimate of the amount payable before you give it, and you should.
What falls due is the Recoverable Amount: unpaid rentals, plus the present value of every rental that would have fallen due to the end of the term, plus the present value of any shortfall between the sale proceeds and the residual, plus the financier's repossession, storage and sale costs. Future amounts are discounted at only 70% of the implicit rate, which makes the present value higher than a full-rate discount would.
Depending on how much of the term has run, that total can exceed what the car is currently worth. Vehicle Solutions does not set it; the financier does.
So is there a saving?
Often yes, and sometimes substantially — the sample 60-month estimate on a $150,000 salary claims $48,816 in total tax savings across the term. But that figure belongs to that salary and that vehicle.
Your own answer is the tax effect, minus everything above. The number that captures it is the effect on your take-home pay, which the quote states, and the residual, which it also states. Compare those two between offers and ignore the headlines.
Frequently asked questions
Is the interest rate shown on the quote?
No. Ask for it explicitly, because you cannot compare the finance component without it.
Is the $395 the only fee the packager charges?
Yes. Vehicle Solutions charges $395 a year and nothing else. The financier's fees are separate and are listed above.
Does Vehicle Solutions earn anything else?
Yes — a commission paid by the financier, calculated on the finance written each month. It is not charged to you.
What does the financier charge if I pay late?
$35 if an instalment is more than five days late, plus interest at the implicit rate plus 4% a year, accruing daily.
Who is liable for the residual?
You are, personally, under the novation agreement — even though the rest of the lease is novated to your employer.
What if the car sells for less than the residual?
You pay the difference on demand. That is the shortfall risk the residual creates.
Does the EV exemption remove the reportable amount?
No. An exempt electric car still produces a reportable value that counts in income tests.
How much notice do I need to end the lease early?
Not less than 14 days, in writing, expiring on a payment date, and the notice cannot be withdrawn.
Can the early payout exceed the car's value?
Yes, depending on how much of the term has run. Ask for an estimate before giving notice.
Are unscheduled repairs covered?
No. Only scheduled servicing, tyres, registration and insurance are covered, alongside fuel and the lease itself.
What is the single most common hidden cost?
An optimistic running-cost budget, because it makes a quote look cheaper without changing what the car actually costs.
How do I get all of this as figures for my own case?
Ask for a quote showing the residual, the budgets line by line, the administration fee and the effect on your take-home pay, then ask separately for the interest rate. Call (08) 8338 4427.
Related pages
- Do novated leases save you money?
- Residual value
- Comparing novated leasing quotes
- How novated leasing works
- Novated lease calculator
- Frequently asked questions
Images on This Page
-
https://vehiclesolutions.com.au/images/vsa-logo-white.svg
Vehicle Solutions Australia logo
-
https://vehiclesolutions.com.au/storage/blog-posts/95/122598/save-money.jpg
(no alt text)