Novated lease pros and cons
Thousands of Australians use novated leasing instead of buying outright or taking a car loan. Like any financial product it suits some people and not others.
Here is an honest account of both sides.
What a novated lease is
A three-way agreement between you, your employer and a financier. The financier owns the vehicle for the term. Your employer takes on the lease obligations through a deed of novation and deducts the lease payment and running costs from your pre-tax salary.
It is not a company car. You choose the vehicle, you drive it for whatever purpose you like, and the arrangement is built around private use.
The pros
Pre-tax treatment. Amounts paid from pre-tax salary reduce the income you are taxed on. The saving is at your marginal rate on the sacrificed amount.
Running costs bundled. Fuel or charging, servicing, tyres, registration renewals and comprehensive insurance become one predictable deduction instead of bills arriving through the year.
The GST structure. The financier claims the GST credit on the vehicle, so less is financed, and your employer claims the GST on running costs. Note that these are credits claimed by the parties entitled to claim them — an employee cannot claim GST credits on a packaged car.
The electric car exemption. For an eligible EV there is no FBT on the car or on registration, insurance, repairs, maintenance and charging. It is the largest concession available on a vehicle in Australia and has no equivalent for a cash purchase.
Choice. No approved list, no manufacturer restriction, and you can usually choose where to buy and which insurer to use.
Fleet pricing. Depending on the make and model, a lease can give access to pricing you would not get as a private buyer.
The cons
You do not own the car. The financier does, for the whole term. You build no equity in it, which is precisely why a residual remains payable.
The residual. A lump sum at the end, set as a percentage of the amount financed — the ATO minimum is 46.88% on a three-year lease — and it does not move with what the car turns out to be worth.
It depends on your employer. They must offer salary packaging and agree to the novation. If they will not, there is no arrangement to have, however good the tax treatment looks.
It is tied to your job. The novation normally ends when you change employer. A new employer may agree to take it on; if not, you manage the obligations yourself — paying the lease out in full or making the payments directly.
Leaving early is expensive. You must be told the total cost, and the payout may exceed the vehicle's current market value, plus early repayment and administration fees.
The reportable amount. Where reportable benefits exceed $2,000 in taxable value in an FBT year, the grossed-up figure goes on your income statement and is counted in income tests — study loan repayments, the Medicare levy surcharge, the private health insurance rebate, Family Tax Benefit, Child Care Subsidy and child support. It applies to eligible electric cars too, because the exemption removes the FBT and not the reporting.
Budgets can be set optimistically. A quote with low fuel, tyre or servicing assumptions looks cheaper and leaves a shortfall you fund after tax.
Who it suits
It tends to suit someone with a marginal rate high enough for the pre-tax treatment to matter, whose employer offers packaging, who would have financed the car anyway, and who wants the running costs handled.
It tends not to suit someone who would otherwise pay cash and keep the car a long time, who expects to change jobs or circumstances mid-term, who is close to a threshold where the reportable amount would bite, or whose employer does not offer it.
The questions that decide it
- Does my employer offer it, and will they novate? Payroll, before anything else.
- What is my projected reportable amount? Ask payroll, and run it against the income tests that apply to you.
- Can I meet the residual? It is a fixed percentage of the amount financed.
- Is my annual distance realistic? It sets three of the five running-cost budgets.
- How likely am I to need out early? The payout can exceed market value.
Frequently asked questions
Is a novated lease worth it?
It depends on your marginal rate, your employer's policy, the vehicle and whether the reportable amount affects your income tests. There is no universal answer.
Do I own the car?
No. The financier owns it during the term, which is why a residual remains payable at the end.
What is the biggest drawback?
Usually the residual, because it is a fixed percentage of the amount financed and falls due as a lump sum.
Can I take the car to a new job?
The novation normally ends with the employment. A new employer may agree to novate; if they will not, the obligations revert to you.
What happens if I leave my job mid-lease?
You manage the obligations yourself — either paying out the lease in full or making the payments directly — unless a new employer novates it.
Is an electric car always better?
An eligible EV removes the FBT, which is a large advantage. Whether the total is lower still depends on the vehicle, the price and your distance.
Does it affect my family payments?
It can. The reportable fringe benefits amount is counted in the Family Tax Benefit and Child Care Subsidy income tests.
Can I claim the GST?
No. The financier claims it on the vehicle and your employer on the running costs. An employee cannot claim GST credits on a packaged car.
How much does it cost to get out early?
You must be told the total. Be aware the payout can exceed the car's market value, and early repayment and administration fees may apply.
Can I choose any car?
Largely. The constraints are your employer's policy, the financier's age and condition criteria, and the FBT definition of a car.
Does it reduce my superannuation?
Salary sacrifice interacts with the super guarantee, and the treatment of a sacrificed car amount is a question for your employer and your own adviser.
How do I decide?
Get the deduction from the calculator, the reportable amount from payroll, and the residual from a quote. Call (08) 8338 4427 and we will go through all three.
Related pages
- Do novated leases save you money?
- Novated lease vs buying outright
- What happens if I change my job?
- Residual value
- Novated lease calculator
- Frequently asked questions
Images on This Page
-
https://vehiclesolutions.com.au/images/vsa-logo-white.svg
Vehicle Solutions Australia logo
-
https://vehiclesolutions.com.au/storage/blog-posts/78/122581/novated-lease-pros-and-cons.jpg
(no alt text)