Why leasing your next vehicle is worth considering

Most people buy a car and then discover what it cost them. A lease makes you confront the cost at the start, which is uncomfortable and considerably more useful.

This page is about one idea: a car is a service you consume over time, and leasing prices that service explicitly instead of hiding it inside an asset you own and later sell at a loss. Whether that suits you is a separate question, and the second half of this page is about when it does not.

What you actually pay for when you buy a car

Buying looks like a purchase and behaves like a subscription.

Over three years you hand over the full price, then recover part of it when you sell. The difference is depreciation, and it is the largest single cost of owning a modern car — larger than fuel, larger than servicing, usually larger than interest.

The trap is that depreciation is invisible until the day you sell. Nothing arrives in the post. There is no monthly line item. So the cost that dominates the arithmetic is the one most people never budget for, and they discover its size exactly once, at the worst possible moment, when they need the money for the next car.

Leasing does not make depreciation disappear. It makes you look at it.

Where the depreciation sits on a novated lease

During the term, the financier owns the vehicle. You are a bailee — you have the right to use it for the lease term, and no more than that. The finance lease terms are explicit that the goods are the financier's property and that the agreement grants you no option to purchase.

That sounds restrictive. Financially, it is the whole point.

Because the financier owns the car, the amount you finance is split in two: the part you pay down over the term, and the residual, a percentage of the amount financed that falls due at the end. The residual is depreciation, named and scheduled. On a three-year lease it is 46.88% of the amount financed under the ATO minimum, which is the figure Vehicle Solutions uses. See residual value for how it is set and why it cannot be set lower.

So the question a lease forces on you at the start is the one buyers face at the end: what will this car be worth when I am done with it, and who carries the risk if I am wrong?

Who carries the risk

This is the part worth being precise about, because it cuts both ways.

If the car is worth more than the residual, the gain is yours. Pay out the residual and sell, and the difference is yours to keep. Vehicle Solutions makes contact three months before the end of the term to work through the options, and this is the one people are usually pleased about.

If the car is worth less than the residual, the loss is yours too. The novation agreement is explicit: despite everything else being novated to your employer, you remain personally liable for payments relating to the residual value. And if you simply return the vehicle, the financier sells it and you pay the shortfall between the sale proceeds and the residual on demand.

A lease does not transfer the depreciation risk away from you. It transfers the timing and the visibility. You agree the number at the start instead of discovering it at the end.

What the lease does take off you

Three things genuinely move.

The capital. You are not tying up a lump sum in a depreciating asset, and you are not borrowing against the house to avoid doing so.

The budgeting. Fuel or charging, tyres, scheduled servicing, registration renewals and comprehensive insurance go into one deduction. They still cost what they cost, but they stop arriving as surprises. How novated leasing works sets out the mechanics.

The tax treatment. The deduction comes from pre-tax salary, which is the reason the arrangement exists at all, and on an eligible electric car there is no FBT. That is a genuinely large concession and it is covered on EV novated leasing.

The honest comparison with buying outright

If you have the cash, no debt, and you intend to keep the car for a decade, buying outright is usually cheaper. Nobody charges you interest, there is no administration fee, and the long tail of ownership after the car has finished depreciating steeply is where the value is. A lease cannot beat that.

The case for a lease strengthens as the facts move away from that picture: you do not have the cash, you would otherwise borrow, you replace the car every three to five years, you are on a high marginal rate, your employer offers packaging, or you are buying an eligible electric vehicle.

Do novated leases save you money? works the numbers through rather than asserting an answer.

What the lease asks of you in return

Ownership is loose. A lease is not. The finance terms set real obligations:

None of these is onerous for normal use. All of them matter if your plans are unusual.

When leasing is the wrong answer

Frequently asked questions

Do I own the car during a novated lease?

No. The financier owns it and you are a bailee with the right to use it for the term. The agreement gives you no contractual option to buy it.

If I do not own it, how can I end up owning it?

By paying the residual at the end of the term. Ownership passes on that payment, not before.

Is depreciation avoided by leasing?

No. It is named as the residual and scheduled from the start, which is a different thing from being avoided.

What happens if the car is worth more than the residual?

Pay out the residual and sell, and the difference is yours tax-free. That is one of the three end-of-term options.

What happens if it is worth less?

You pay the shortfall. If you return the vehicle, the financier sells it and bills you the difference between the proceeds and the residual.

Can I use a leased car for rideshare or deliveries?

The finance terms prohibit use as a taxi or hire car, and prohibit motor sport entirely. Ask before you assume a particular platform is acceptable.

Can I modify or accessorise the vehicle?

Not without prior written consent, which cannot be unreasonably withheld. Any addition becomes part of the financier's security.

Who chooses the insurer?

You do. Vehicle Solutions sells no insurance and has no insurer panel. The financier has to approve the insurer and be noted as owner and first loss payee.

Can I take the car interstate?

Yes for ordinary travel. Keeping it outside your state or territory for more than a month needs written consent, and taking it out of Australia always does.

Is buying outright ever cheaper?

Yes — if you have the cash, would not otherwise borrow, and intend to keep the car long enough to get past the steep part of the depreciation curve.

Does the term change how much depreciation I carry?

Yes. The residual percentage falls with the term, from 65.63% at one year to 28.13% at five, so a longer lease pays down more of the car and leaves less at the end.

How do I see this as a number for my own situation?

Run the novated lease calculator, then ask for a quote showing the residual, the fees and the effect on your take-home pay. Call (08) 8338 4427.

Related pages

Images on This Page