Comparing novated leasing quotes
Two quotes on the same car, from two providers, can differ by a surprising amount per pay cycle — and the reason is usually not the interest rate.
It is almost always the assumptions. Here is how to compare properly, and what a quote is actually required to tell you.
Start with what a quote must disclose
Here is what to insist on seeing in any quote before you compare it with another:
- details of the vehicle, including all options and accessories
- the proposed term, which typically runs from one to five years
- the estimated salary deductions, including lease payments and budgeted items such as a fuel card, servicing, comprehensive insurance and roadside assistance
- the pre-tax and post-tax amounts making up the deduction, and the resulting impact on your take-home pay
- administration fees and document fees
- whether any commissions may be paid or received, and by whom
- the residual value you are liable for at the end, exclusive of GST
- all relevant taxes payable on the purchase, such as stamp duty and luxury car tax where applicable, and information on the FBT value
The financier's lease agreement separately sets out the rental payments, the term, any commissions, and the residual inclusive of GST.
If a quote is missing any of these, ask for them before comparing. A quote you cannot take apart is not comparable.
The five things that actually move the number
1. The term. A longer term lowers the residual percentage and the deduction, but you pay finance for longer. Compare quotes on the same term or you are not comparing anything.
2. The residual. It must be at least the ATO minimum for the term — 65.63% at one year, 56.25% at two, 46.88% at three, 37.5% at four, 28.13% at five. A higher residual lowers the deduction and leaves a bigger lump sum at the end. And check whether the figure you are shown includes GST, because the packager and the financier quote it on different bases.
3. The running-cost budgets. This is the big one. Fuel or charging, servicing, tyres, registration and insurance are all estimates. Assume fewer kilometres, longer service intervals or one less set of tyres and the quote looks cheaper — until the budget runs short. Ask each provider what annual distance, how many services and how many tyres their figures assume.
4. The fees. Administration and documentation fees, and any commissions. These must be disclosed, so get them as figures rather than a line saying "fees apply".
5. The vehicle price. Two providers sourcing the same car at different prices will produce different payments regardless of everything else.
Compare take-home pay, not the deduction
The deduction on its own tells you very little, because the pre-tax and post-tax split changes what it actually costs you. The Code requires the quote to show the impact on your take-home pay, and that is the number to put side by side.
A quote with a larger deduction but a different split can leave you better off than one with a smaller deduction.
A checklist
Before you choose:
- Same car, same options, same term on every quote.
- Residual percentage stated, and whether it is inclusive or exclusive of GST.
- Running-cost budgets itemised, with the kilometre and servicing assumptions behind them.
- Administration and document fees as dollar figures.
- Commission disclosure — who is paid what, by whom.
- The effect on take-home pay, not just the deduction.
- Whether comprehensive insurance is in the package or sourced separately.
- What happens if you leave your employer, in writing.
One thing worth more than a cheaper quote
If you have a study or training loan, receive family assistance or pay child support, the reportable fringe benefits amount can affect you more than the difference between two quotes. A novated lease normally produces one where the taxable value exceeds $2,000 in an FBT year, and it is counted in income tests.
That figure is worth asking about alongside the price.
Frequently asked questions
Why are two quotes on the same car so different?
Usually the running-cost budgets and the term rather than the finance rate. A thinner fuel, servicing or tyre budget makes a quote look cheaper and costs more later, which is why the assumptions behind each figure matter more than the total.
Should I compare the deduction or the take-home effect?
The take-home effect. The pre-tax and post-tax split changes what a given deduction actually costs you, so the only comparable number is the stated impact on your take-home pay. A Vehicle Solutions quote states it as a fortnightly figure, alongside a payslip comparison with and without the lease.
Does the quote have to disclose commissions?
Yes. The Code requires a quote to state whether any commissions may be paid or received in relation to the lease, and by whom. Ask for it explicitly if it is not visible.
Is the residual the same in every quote?
Not necessarily. It must be at least the ATO minimum for the term, but it can be set higher, which lowers the deduction and increases the final lump sum. Compare the percentage, not just the payment.
Why do two quotes show different residual figures for the same car?
Often because one is exclusive of GST and the other inclusive. The salary packager discloses it exclusive, the financier inclusive. Check the basis before concluding anything.
What annual distance should the budget assume?
Your actual distance. If a quote assumes 15,000 km and you drive 25,000, the fuel and tyre budgets will run short. This is the single most common cause of a budget shortfall.
Are fees negotiable?
That is a commercial question for each provider. What matters for comparison is that the fees are disclosed as figures so you can include them in the total rather than discovering them later.
Should I get more than one quote?
Comparing is sensible for any significant finance decision, provided you compare like with like — same car, same term, same budget assumptions. An apparently cheaper quote built on thinner budgets is not actually cheaper.
Does the cheapest quote mean the lowest total cost?
Not reliably. Total cost includes the deduction over the term, the fees, the residual and any shortfall if the budgets were set light. Compare the whole cost of the arrangement.
What if a provider will not itemise the budget?
That is a reason for caution. The Code requires the estimated deductions and the budgeted components to be disclosed, so an itemised budget is what you should expect rather than a favour.
Does insurance have to be in the package?
No. Comprehensive insurance is mandatory for the lease term, but you may source your own provided it meets the novation agreement's terms. Whether it sits inside the package changes the deduction, so check which basis each quote uses.
Can you explain a competitor's quote to me?
We are happy to go through any quote line by line so you can see what each figure assumes — including ours. Call (08) 8338 4427.
Related pages
- Novated lease information in detail
- What is a fully maintained novated lease?
- Residual value explained
- Novated lease calculator
- Frequently asked questions
Images on This Page
-
https://vehiclesolutions.com.au/images/vsa-logo-white.svg
Vehicle Solutions Australia logo
-
https://vehiclesolutions.com.au/storage/blog-posts/25/122528/employee-novated-lease-benefits.jpg
(no alt text)